Index CFDs explained: how they track an index, what margin you need and what they cost
An index CFD lets you trade the rise or fall of a whole stock index without buying any of its shares. Here is how the price is set, how much margin EU and UK retail rules require, which costs apply and where the risks lie.
A stock index measures the combined value of a group of shares. The FTSE 100 follows the largest companies on the London Stock Exchange, the S&P 500 follows 500 large US companies, and Germany's DAX follows the biggest firms on the Frankfurt exchange. You cannot buy an index directly, but you can trade products whose price follows it. An index CFD is one of them.
This guide covers what an index CFD is, how its price is linked to the index, how margin works under the European retail rules, which costs apply, and the risks you take on. If contracts for difference are new to you, start with our introduction to CFD trading.
What is an index CFD?
A CFD, or contract for difference, is an agreement between you and a provider to exchange the difference between the price of an asset when you open a trade and its price when you close it. With an index CFD the asset is a stock index. If you buy (go long) and the index rises, the provider pays you the difference. If it falls, you pay the provider. If you sell (go short), the result is reversed.
You never own the shares that make up the index, you have no voting rights and the trade takes place over the counter with the provider rather than on an exchange. In most cases the provider is also your counterparty, which means the money you lose is the money it gains, and the other way round. ESMA, the EU securities regulator, describes this business model in its 2018 decision on CFDs.
How the price follows the index
Providers usually express an index CFD in points, the same unit as the index itself, and let you choose a value per point, for example 1 euro or 10 euros. Your profit or loss is the number of points the price moves multiplied by that value.
The CFD price is not always identical to the index level you see in the news. Most providers build their quote from the index futures market, because futures trade almost around the clock while the underlying shares only trade during exchange hours. A futures price includes the cost of interest and the dividends expected before expiry, so providers adjust it back to a “fair value” for the cash index. Then they add a spread: a buy price slightly above that value and a sell price slightly below it.
A worked example with retail margin
In 2018 ESMA set minimum initial margins for retail clients that depend on the underlying. For CFDs on ten major indices (FTSE 100, CAC 40, DAX, Dow Jones Industrial Average, S&P 500, NASDAQ Composite, NASDAQ 100, Nikkei 225, ASX 200 and EURO STOXX 50) the minimum is 5% of the position value, which equals leverage of 20:1. For any other equity index it is 10%, or 10:1. These figures come from Annex I of the decision.
Take a hypothetical major index at 10,000 points and a long CFD at 2 euros per point. The position is worth 20,000 euros (10,000 points times 2 euros).
- Minimum initial margin at 5%: 1,000 euros.
- If the index rises 2% to 10,200 points, the gain is 200 points times 2 euros, or 400 euros, before costs.
- If the index falls 2% to 9,800 points, the loss is 400 euros, 40% of the margin.
- If it falls 3% to 9,700 points, the loss is 600 euros, 60% of the margin.
The same rules require a margin close-out: the provider must close one or more positions when the funds in your account fall below half of the initial margin needed for your open trades. If you had deposited exactly 1,000 euros, the 3% fall would leave 400 euros, below the 500 euro threshold, and the position would be closed at a loss. On a non-major index the same 20,000 euro position would need at least 2,000 euros of margin.
A small move in the index becomes a large move in your account. Our guides to leverage and margin trading explain the mechanics in more detail.
Where the rules come from
The ESMA measures applied from 1 August 2018 and were renewed every three months. On 31 July 2019 ESMA let them expire because most national regulators had adopted permanent rules of their own that were at least as strict. In the UK, the FCA made similar rules permanent from 1 August 2019: leverage limits between 30:1 and 2:1, close-out at 50% of required margin, negative balance protection and a standard risk warning. Professional clients are not covered by these limits, and rules outside the EU and UK can differ.
What an index CFD costs
Spread
The difference between the buy and sell price is the first cost you pay. You start every trade slightly behind, and spreads are often wider outside the main trading hours of the index.
Overnight financing
Because a leveraged position works like borrowed exposure, providers charge financing for each night a cash index CFD stays open. ESMA notes that these daily or overnight charges can include a mark-up set by the provider. On a position held for weeks or months, financing can outweigh the spread.
Dividend adjustments
When the shares in an index go ex-dividend, their prices drop and so does the index. To make up for that, providers usually credit long positions in a cash index CFD and debit short positions by an amount based on the expected dividends. Short sellers should factor this in, especially in months when many constituents pay out.
Other charges
Some providers add a commission on each trade or account management fees. ESMA lists the number and complexity of these charges as one reason retail clients struggle to judge what CFDs really cost.
Cash index CFDs and futures-based index CFDs
| Cash index CFD | Futures-based index CFD | |
|---|---|---|
| Price reference | The cash index, derived from futures at fair value | A specific futures contract month |
| End date | None, stays open until you close it | Expires with the futures contract unless rolled over |
| Overnight financing | Charged each night | No separate charge, financing is built into the price |
| Dividend adjustments | Credited or debited as shares go ex-dividend | Expected dividends are already in the futures price |
| Spread | Usually tighter | Usually wider |
| Typical use | Short-term trades over days | Positions planned for weeks or months |
The choice is mostly about holding period. Daily financing adds up on a cash CFD, while the wider spread of a futures-based CFD costs more on a trade that lasts only hours. For a closer look at the exchange-traded contracts behind these prices, see our comparison of CFDs and futures.
Risks of trading index CFDs
- Leverage cuts both ways. At 20:1 a 5% move against you equals your whole initial margin.
- Gaps. Indices can open far from the previous close after news released while the market was shut. A stop loss is not a guarantee: it triggers a market order, and the price you get can be worse than your stop level.
- Costs over time. Overnight financing and dividend adjustments keep running while a position is open.
- Counterparty risk. Your contract is with the provider, not an exchange or clearing house, so its financial strength and the way it holds client money matter.
- Most retail accounts lose money. When ESMA introduced its rules, national regulators had found that 74% to 89% of retail CFD accounts lost money. Providers must now publish the share of their own retail accounts that lose money.
Negative balance protection means a retail client in the EU or UK cannot lose more than the money in the CFD account, but that whole balance can go. An index fund or ETF gives exposure to the same index without leverage, financing charges or margin calls, which suits a long-term holding better.
Sources
Margin levels, close-out, negative balance protection, cost descriptions and loss figures: ESMA Decision (EU) 2018/796 and the ESMA press release of 27 March 2018. End of the EU-wide measures: ESMA statement of 31 July 2019. UK rules: FCA.
Frequently asked questions
What is an index CFD?
It is a contract for difference whose price follows a stock index such as the FTSE 100, DAX or S&P 500. You agree with a provider to exchange the difference between the opening and closing price of the contract. You never own the shares in the index.
How much margin do I need for an index CFD?
Under the retail rules ESMA introduced in 2018 and national regulators later made permanent, the minimum initial margin is 5% of the position value (leverage of 20:1) for major indices such as the FTSE 100, DAX, S&P 500 and Nikkei 225, and 10% (10:1) for other equity indices. Providers can ask for more.
Do index CFDs pay dividends?
You do not receive dividends because you own no shares. On cash index CFDs providers usually make a dividend adjustment instead: long positions are credited and short positions debited when the index constituents go ex-dividend.
What is the difference between a cash index CFD and a futures-based index CFD?
A cash index CFD has no fixed end date and is charged overnight financing for each night it stays open. A futures-based index CFD follows an index futures contract, expires with that contract unless rolled over, carries no separate overnight charge and usually has a wider spread.
Can I lose more than my deposit with an index CFD?
For retail clients in the EU and UK, negative balance protection limits losses to the money in the CFD account. You can still lose all of that money quickly, and regulators found that 74% to 89% of retail CFD accounts lose money.