CFD vs futures: how the two contracts differ
A CFD and a futures contract can follow the same index or commodity, yet they are built very differently. One is a private agreement with a provider, the other a standard contract traded on an exchange and guaranteed by a clearing house. Here is what that means for margin, costs, risk and access.
Contracts for difference and futures look alike from a distance. Both are derivatives, both let you profit from a rise or a fall in price, and both ask you to put down only a fraction of the position value as margin. The differences sit underneath: where the contract trades, who stands on the other side, how long it lasts and what it costs to hold.
This guide compares the two for a private trader. If either product is new to you, our introductions to CFD trading and futures contracts cover the basics.
What a CFD is
A CFD is an agreement between you and a provider to exchange the difference between the price of an asset when you open the trade and its price when you close it. You never own the share, index or barrel of oil. The provider sets the contract terms, and you can usually choose a position size in small steps, for example a value per index point.
ESMA, the EU securities regulator, notes in its 2018 decision on CFDs that they are typically not traded on a trading venue and that their pricing, trading terms and settlement are not standardised. In practice this means a CFD is an over the counter contract with one firm.
What a futures contract is
A futures contract is an agreement to buy or sell a set quantity of an asset at a price fixed today, for delivery or cash settlement on a future date. The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission explains on its page on how futures markets work that exchanges set standardised contract terms, including the quantity to be delivered, so traders mainly agree on price. Each contract has a fixed expiry month.
Few traders hold a contract to delivery. The CFTC says most futures, by volume, are closed out by an offsetting trade before that point. A trader who wants to keep the exposure past expiry rolls the position: closes the expiring contract and opens the next one.
Side by side
| CFD | Futures | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it trades | Over the counter, with the provider | On a regulated exchange |
| Contract terms | Set by the provider, flexible size | Standardised by the exchange, fixed size |
| Expiry | Usually none on cash CFDs | Fixed expiry month, roll to keep exposure |
| Your counterparty | The provider | The clearing house |
| Holding cost | Overnight financing each night | Built into the price, plus costs of rolling |
| Retail leverage | 30:1 to 2:1 in the EU and UK | Margin typically 2% to 10% of contract value |
| Loss limit | Negative balance protection for EU and UK retail clients | Losses can exceed the initial margin |
| US retail access | Generally not available | Available through CFTC registered firms |
Exchange and clearing against a single provider
When you trade futures, your order meets other orders on the exchange. Once the trade is matched, a clearing house steps in. In the CFTC's words, it acts as the buyer to all sellers and the seller to all buyers. You do not depend on whoever took the other side, and every participant posts margin with the clearing system each day.
With a CFD your contract is with the provider, which often keeps the other side of your trade. ESMA describes the conflict this creates: a provider that does not hedge client trades gains when clients lose. ESMA also pointed to the risk of less transparent reference prices and of slippage being passed on unevenly. The price you trade at is the provider's quote, usually based on the underlying market or its futures, and the provider's financial strength and the way it holds client money matter to you.
Margin and leverage
Futures
Futures margin is a performance bond, not a down payment. The CFTC puts it typically between 2% and 10% of the contract value, which works out to leverage of roughly 10 to 50 times. Positions are marked to market every day: gains are credited, losses debited, and if the account falls below the maintenance level you must add money. The risk disclosure statement for security futures published by the National Futures Association states that a position can gain or lose many times the initial margin deposit.
CFDs
For retail clients in the EU, ESMA set leverage limits in 2018: 30:1 for major currency pairs, 20:1 for non-major pairs, gold and major indices, 10:1 for other commodities and non-major indices, 5:1 for single shares and other underlyings, and 2:1 for cryptocurrencies. A provider must close positions when your funds fall to 50% of the required margin, and negative balance protection caps your total loss at the money in the account. National regulators later adopted these rules permanently; the FCA applied the same limits in the UK from 1 August 2019. Professional clients and clients of firms outside these rules can face higher leverage and no loss cap.
Leverage works in both directions in both products. Our guides to leverage and margin trading show how a small price move turns into a large change in your account.
Overnight financing against rolling
A cash CFD has no end date, so the provider charges financing for each night the position stays open. ESMA notes that these daily or overnight charges can include a mark-up, and that the number and complexity of CFD costs make them hard for retail clients to judge. On a position held for weeks, financing can cost more than the spread.
A futures contract has no separate overnight charge. The cost of carrying the asset until expiry is already in the futures price, which is why it differs from the spot price. The trade off is the roll: to stay in the market past expiry you pay the spread and any commission again on two trades. Some providers also offer futures based CFDs that follow a futures month and expire with it; our guide to index CFDs compares the two kinds.
Other costs
CFD providers earn mainly from the spread, and some add commission on share CFDs. ESMA points out that transaction fees apply to the full notional value of a trade, so their weight grows with leverage. Futures traders pay a commission to the broker, exchange and clearing fees, and the bid and ask spread of the market. Because futures contracts come in fixed sizes, a small account may find even one contract too large for sensible risk control, while a CFD can be sized down.
Who can trade them where
In the United States, the law on swaps keeps CFDs away from most private traders. Section 2(e) of the Commodity Exchange Act makes it unlawful for anyone who is not an eligible contract participant to enter into a swap unless it is traded on, or under the rules of, a designated contract market. CFDs are over the counter contracts, so US retail clients generally cannot use them. Futures, by contrast, must with limited exceptions be traded on an exchange through firms registered with the CFTC, and firms that handle customer money must also register with the National Futures Association, according to the CFTC's futures market basics.
In the EU and UK both products are available to retail clients, with the CFD restrictions above. Rules elsewhere differ, so check what applies in your country and to the firm you use.
Risks you take with either
- Most retail CFD accounts lose money. When ESMA brought in its measures, national regulators had found that 74% to 89% of retail CFD accounts typically lost money. Providers must now publish the share of their own retail accounts that lose money.
- Futures losses are not capped at your deposit. Daily settlement can call for more money at short notice, and a gap in price can take an account below zero.
- Leverage magnifies small moves. At 20:1, a 5% move against you equals the whole initial margin.
- Counterparty and pricing risk with CFDs. You rely on one provider for prices, execution and the safety of your money.
Neither product suits money you cannot afford to lose. For long term exposure to an index or commodity, an unleveraged fund avoids margin calls and financing costs altogether.
Sources
CFD characteristics, conflicts of interest and costs: ESMA Decision (EU) 2018/796. Leverage limits and loss figures: ESMA press release, March 2018. UK rules: FCA. Futures standardisation, clearing and margin: CFTC and the NFA security futures risk disclosure. US access: 7 U.S.C. § 2(e) and the CFTC futures market basics.
Frequently asked questions
Is a CFD the same as a futures contract?
No. Both let you gain or lose from a price move without owning the asset, but a futures contract is a standardised agreement traded on an exchange and cleared by a clearing house, with a fixed expiry date. A CFD is an agreement with a provider, usually traded over the counter, with sizes set by the provider and often no expiry.
Which has higher leverage, CFDs or futures?
It depends on the market and the rules that apply to you. The CFTC says futures margin is typically between 2% and 10% of the contract value. For retail CFD clients in the EU and UK, leverage is capped between 30:1 and 2:1 depending on the asset, which means margin of about 3.3% to 50%.
Can US residents trade CFDs?
CFDs are generally not offered to retail clients in the United States. US law makes it unlawful for anyone who is not an eligible contract participant to enter into a swap unless it is traded on, or under the rules of, a designated contract market. CFDs are traded over the counter, so they do not meet that condition.
Do futures have overnight financing charges like CFDs?
No separate charge. The cost of holding the position is built into the futures price. If you want to keep exposure past expiry you roll the position, closing the expiring contract and opening a later one, which means paying the spread and any commissions again.
Can I lose more than my deposit?
With futures, yes: a position can gain or lose many times the initial margin, and you must meet margin calls. Retail CFD clients in the EU and UK have negative balance protection that limits losses to the money in the CFD account. In both cases you can lose your whole deposit quickly.